REVIEW: The Book of Tomorrow by Cecelia Ahern

19. The Book of Tomorrow by Cecelia Ahern
Publication: Harper (January 25, 2011), ARC, 310pp / ISBN 0061706302
Genre: Fiction, Magic Realism

Rating: Borrow it
Read: February 8, 2011

Source: Publisher

Summary from Amazon:

Born into the lap of luxury and comfortable in the here and now, spoiled, tempestuous Tamara Goodwin has never had to look to the future—until the abrupt death of her father leaves her and her mother a mountain of debt and forces them to move in with Tamara’s peculiar aunt and uncle in a tiny countryside village.

Tamara is lonely and bored, with a traveling library as her only diversion. There she finds a large leather-bound book with a gold clasp and padlock, but no author name or title. Intrigued, she pries open the lock, and what she finds inside takes her breath away.

Tamara sees entries written in her own handwriting, and dated for the following day. When the next day unfolds exactly as recorded, Tamara realizes she may have found a solution to her problems. But in her quest to find answers, Tamara soon learns that some pages are better left unturned and that, try as she may, she mustn’t interfere with fate.

Review

It’s taken me a while to figure out what I wanted to say about this book, because while I enjoyed it and had fun reading it, there was something about it that was bothering me. That something was actually bothering me so much it was making it hard to me to sleep at night, because I’d be laying there wondering wtf it was that was pinging my Wrong! radar. Then I had to tell myself to stop thinking about it because I had to be up early in the morning to catch a bus– anyway, I didn’t figure out what the something was until Wednesday night.

Here’s the something: I didn’t believe in the characters. I didn’t believe that Tamara was an actual 16-year-old girl; she felt more like an adult’s IDEA of a 16-year-old girl, one that was trying too hard to fit into that mold of “stuff teenagers like” (big hair, The Ting Tangs, Facebook) and it all came off as really false.

On the other hand, Tamara did say that she felt she had aged several years in the time since her father’s funeral, so maybe the two sides of her– adult and teen– weren’t playing nice together, and that’s what I picked up on.

But Tamara wasn’t the only problem. None of the other characters felt real to me, either, except maybe Tamara’s crazy aunt, and even that was a push. And then the crazy aunt got shoved into the “not real” side of things in the big reveal bit at the end of the book and it all went to hell.

The author

I didn’t like that ending. It felt like it happened too quickly, with too much shoved into too few pages, and the aunt became even more of a caricature with no real personality or even personhood. It was like a bad mystery show, one that was made on a budget of $2 and a limited time to shoot. Plus, the end had a flashback sequence narrated by an omniscient observer that I completely hated– mostly because it was SO different from the rest of the book.

However! Despite the fact that I didn’t believe in the characters and hated the ending, I really enjoyed the story. It was super suspenseful, with some scary parts and really nice descriptions of the Irish countryside, and it had a great mystery. It moved really quickly and I wasn’t bored the whole time I read it.

Because I do place so much importance on characters, though, the awesome story wasn’t enough to up my rating from “Borrow it.” I’d definitely read another of Cecelia Ahern’s books, and it’s not like I think this one is a complete wash. I just wish the characters had been a bit more layered.

Basically: If you place importance on story more than characters, or if you don’t mind slightly unrealistic characters, then the story is enough to make this a really good book.
If you like: Gothic romances, magical realism, those true crime shows on TruTV, Lifetime movies with titles like “I Had My Sister’s Baby,” you’ll like this book.

They say a story loses something with each telling. If that is the case, this story has lost nothing, for it’s the first time it’s been told.

This story is one for which some people will have to suspend their disbelief. If this wasn’t happening to me, I would be one of those people. (Chapter 1)

And

Get your own copy @ Amazon or BookDepository.com and support Birdbrain(ed) Book Blog!

Other reviews: Rhapsody in Books Weblog | Books, Movies, and Chinese Food | Leeswammes’ Blog | GalleySmith | Bookfoolery and Babble

Credit: Author photo lifted from her website.

6 thoughts on “REVIEW: The Book of Tomorrow by Cecelia Ahern”

  1. Thanks for reviewing this. I took it home, and I just couldn’t get into it. I read for character first, and I just couldn’t like Tamara. So, I quit the book, and took it back to the library. I’m glad I read your review, though, and not at all unhappy that I dropped the book. Thanks!

    1. Tamara was a tough cookie, yeah. I think if I was less interested in the story she would have killed any desire in me to read it, so I understand why you quit!

  2. Thanks for mentioning my review.

    I can see what you mean. I also liked the book a lot while I was reading it, and afterwards I also thought, OK, but…? I based my review on my reading experience and that was great.

    But yes, there was something… 🙂

    1. You’re welcome! And I’m glad I’m not the only one who went all “wait, what?” after finishing it. Makes me feel less crazy, lol.

  3. I’ve read two of Ahern’s other books – PS I Love You and The Gift – and had that same “hmmm something was off” feeling afterwards that you described. I have Book of Tomorrow on my shelf and I’m a little bit hesitant to read it. But I’m glad to hear it’s a an enjoyable read!

    1. It is! Mostly. And it does move very quickly, so if you’re not immediately turned off by the characters you might like it. 😀

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.