Diana Wynne Jones Month, Day 10: The Ogre Downstairs (#dwjmarch)

diana wynne jones month march
Today’s topic is about The Ogre Downstairs! Here is the summary for those who haven’t read this book yet:

Diana Wynne Jones at her finest — family feuds and chaos, magic with hilarious results and some of the most original ideas ever to appear between the covers of a book. Casper, Johnny and Gwinny get a big shock when their mother marries the Ogre. The Ogre is large and stern and not at all interested in children, although this doesn’t prevent him from adding his own two awful sons, Douglas and Malcolm, to the family mix. Now the five children and two adults are squashed under the same roof, which can lead to only one thing — war! Then the Ogre brings home the Chemistry Sets — one for Malcolm and one for Johnny. Not that Johnny is impressed by this very obvious bribe. At least, not until they accidentally discover the flying lotion. Then the real fun begins!

Ogre DownstairsI’ve only read The Ogre Downstairs one time, and I need to read it again because apparently the newer editions have updated things since its first printing. For example: instead of ruining tapes, the children apparently ruined vinyls. I don’t remember tapes or vinyls and am now consumed with curiosity. I DO remember something about a disco, which seems like a weird thing to have left un-updated, if you’re updating everything else.

Anyway, according to the Wikipedia page, there’s a very funny secret meaning re:the Hells Angels and their “classical Greek” in the last chapter. I don’t speak any kind of Greek and am feeling somewhat left out; what is it that they said? Anyone know?

She was always putting in little things like that, DWJ. I definitely need some annotated versions of her books, or some kind of encyclopedia of all the interesting things she wove into her stories. Though, of course, half the fun is catching them during subsequent rereadings!

Here’s what I said about The Ogre Downstairs when I reviewed it last year:

Best thing: everyone learning (slowly) how to be a family, mostly through the accidental application of empathy.

Worst thing: mean parent being excused (kind of) for being mean by the revelation that his sense of humor isn’t aligned with anyone else’s. I don’t agree with the assessment, but whatever, it’s not my book.

I’ve always liked how DWJ blends real-life drama with the fantastic, and I particularly like it in The Ogre Downstairs. It’s funny, it’s sad, it’s a little bit scary at times, and I think it’s definitely worth reading if you’re a DWJ fan.

And before you go, here’s a lovely interview with DWJ where she mentions The Ogre Downstairs. Apparently, her husband thought he was the Ogre!

6 thoughts on “Diana Wynne Jones Month, Day 10: The Ogre Downstairs (#dwjmarch)”

  1. I’m just really getting weirded out by these books with changes! Although, maybe an update here or there isn’t a bad idea. But then again, when would you stop? Because obviously tapes is out of date too now and eventually the plot event wouldn’t even make sense because they couldn’t physically ruin audio files. This is all totally separate from that lame whitewashing of Deep Secret though. 😛

    1. I suppose they could be collector’s LPs now or something? People do still have them, just not in the same way as they did before. Although that gets into changing the intent/characterization more than just an outdated technology, which is maybe not good.

  2. But, wait — what? I want the proper one with the vinyl! I don’t want the rubbish edition with the tapes! If you discover what bit of the book has them ruining tapes or ruining vinyl, make sure to tell me about it. I can then be very vigilant about making sure I only buy a copy of the book if it’s got the proper vinyl being ruined.

    Meanwhile, I found a link that transcribes the Greek! :p

    http://www.suberic.net/cgi-bin/dwj/wiki.cgi?action=browse&diff=1&id=The_Ogre_Downstairs_%28Spoilers%29&revision=31

    1. Thank you thank you! It was driving me nuts, tbh.

      I’ll keep an eye out for the relevant part; I tried skimming but couldn’t find it so I suppose that means a reread. Oh no. :p

  3. I’ve only recently caught up with #dwjmonth and #dwjmarch so forgive me for jumping into the middle of it all. ‘The Ogre Downstairs’ is sometimes seen as a ‘problem’ early DWJ story, but I think I’ve winkled out a few clues in my review of it on my WordPress blog: http://wp.me/s2oNj1-ogre
    As I’ve entitled it “Beware geeks bearing gifts” you might gather at some stage that I’d deciphered the “Greek” bits of dialogue!
    I’ve just started to enjoy the post discussions, and am looking forward to following the links. Great to have discovered some more dedicated DWJ followers.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.